Skip to content
How to Select the Right Tenant

Michael Robertson

Finding the right tenant for your rental property is one of the most important tasks for any landlord. When you decide to rent out your property privately, without the help of an agent, it’s even …

How to Select the Right Tenant

Finding the right tenant for your rental property is one of the most important tasks for any landlord. When you decide to rent out your property privately, without the help of an agent, it’s even more crucial to thoroughly vet potential tenants. A reliable tenant will take care of your property, pay rent on time, and be a good neighbor, while the wrong tenant can lead to financial loss and property damage. This guide will walk you through the key steps and considerations for selecting the right tenant when advertising your property for rent without using an agent.

1. Advertise Your Property Effectively

The first step in selecting the right tenant is to get your property in front of as many prospective renters as possible. Advertising your property effectively is essential to attracting a large pool of qualified tenants.

Create a Compelling Listing

Your listing should be clear, concise, and compelling. A good listing will include high-quality photos, a detailed description of the property, and key information such as:

  • Rent price
  • Property size (number of bedrooms, bathrooms, etc.)
  • Location details
  • Public transport and amenities nearby
  • Available move-in date
  • Pet policies (if any)
  • Preferred tenant characteristics (e.g., non-smokers, professionals, etc.)

2. Set Clear Tenant Requirements

Before you begin showing your property to potential tenants, it’s important to set clear requirements for the type of tenant you’re looking for. Establishing these expectations up front can help you save time and prevent misunderstandings down the line.

Tenant Eligibility Criteria

Make sure to set eligibility criteria that reflect what you need in a tenant. For example:

  • Income requirements: Ensure the tenant can comfortably afford the rent by requiring proof of income.
  • Credit history: A background check can reveal whether a tenant is financially responsible.
  • Previous rental references: Contact former landlords to gauge the tenant’s reliability.
  • No criminal history: Ensure the tenant does not have a criminal record, which can pose a risk to your property.

Flexible or Strict Criteria?

Decide if you want to be flexible on certain criteria, such as whether you’ll accept tenants with pets or those who have had past rental issues. While strict criteria can help reduce the risk of problem tenants, being flexible can also open up your pool to a wider range of prospective renters.

3. Conduct Thorough Tenant Screening

Once you’ve gathered applications from interested tenants, it’s time to start the screening process. Screening is one of the most crucial steps in selecting the right tenant, as it ensures you’re renting to someone who will be reliable and respectful of your property.

Verify Tenant Information

Start by verifying the information provided by the prospective tenants. This includes checking:

  • Identification: Request government-issued identification to verify the tenant’s identity.
  • Proof of income: Pay slips, bank statements, or tax returns are useful documents for verifying income.
  • References: Contact previous landlords or property managers to ask about the tenant’s rental history. Ask about payment punctuality, cleanliness, and behavior.

Check Credit History

A tenant’s credit score can offer insight into their financial responsibility. Use a service that allows you to obtain a tenant’s credit report. A poor credit score or history of missed payments may indicate financial instability, which could increase the likelihood of late rent payments or damage to your property.

Conduct Background Checks

Performing a criminal background check is essential to ensure that your tenant does not have a history of violent crime, theft, or other offenses. This can protect you and other tenants in the building or community. You can use various online services to perform background checks.

4. Interview Potential Tenants

Once you’ve narrowed down your list of prospective tenants, conduct an in-person or virtual interview. This step is an opportunity to get to know the tenants better and assess whether they’re a good fit for your property.

Ask the Right Questions

During the interview, ask questions that will help you gauge the tenant’s suitability. Some questions to consider include:

  • Why are you moving?
  • How long do you plan to stay in the property?
  • Do you have pets? (If this is a concern)
  • What is your work situation?
  • What are your hobbies or lifestyle like?
  • Do you have any specific needs or preferences for the property?

Assess Their Communication and Reliability

How a potential tenant communicates with you can also reveal a lot about their reliability. Are they prompt with replies? Do they respect your time and show up for scheduled viewings? Strong communication skills are an important trait in a tenant.

5. Understand Your Rights and Responsibilities

When renting out your property privately, it’s important to understand your legal rights and responsibilities as a landlord. Each state and territory in Australia has specific laws governing tenancy agreements, tenant rights, and eviction procedures.

Rental Agreement

Once you’ve selected the right tenant, make sure to have a written rental agreement in place. This contract should outline:

  • Rent amount and due dates
  • Lease length
  • Bond amount
  • Tenant and landlord responsibilities
  • Rules regarding property maintenance, repairs, and inspections

Know the Termination and Eviction Procedures

While you hope you’ll never have to evict a tenant, it’s important to know the legal procedures for eviction if necessary. Understanding the correct steps for terminating a lease and evicting a tenant can help you avoid legal pitfalls and ensure you follow the law.

6. Be Clear About Expectations and Communication

Clear expectations can prevent many potential conflicts. Once you’ve selected a tenant, ensure that you’re both on the same page regarding important details.

Maintenance and Property Care

Be clear about what your tenants are responsible for when it comes to property maintenance. This includes mowing the lawn, taking out the trash, or cleaning certain parts of the property. Clarifying this in the rental agreement can help avoid misunderstandings later.

Inspect the Property Regularly

Regular property inspections are essential for ensuring that tenants are taking care of the property. In most Australian states, landlords are allowed to inspect the property at regular intervals, usually every 3-6 months. Make sure to give proper notice to tenants before conducting an inspection.

Choosing the right tenant is vital to ensuring that your rental property is well-maintained, your rent is paid on time, and you avoid unnecessary conflicts. By advertising effectively, setting clear requirements, thoroughly screening applicants, and maintaining open communication, you can increase the chances of finding a reliable tenant who will take care of your property. Renting without an agent may require more effort on your part, but it can also give you greater control over the process and potentially save you money. Good luck with your property rental journey!